A Loop Hole in California Landlord Tenant Law

Under California law landlords have to adhere tofor the actual damages, plus special damages of
housing standards and must refrain from usingno less than $100 and not more than $5,000.00.
self help. There are housing standards that ifThe prevailing party is also entitle to reasonable
violated will deem the property untenable,attorney fees and costs.
meaning it cannot be rented out.This does not mean that the tenant can cause
The property is deemed untenable, if itthese conditions and it does not mean thatthe
substantially lacks the following:landlord is liable if the tenant chooses to live in
(1) Effective waterproofing and weathersubstandard conditions. The landlord has no duty
protection of the roof, walls, windows, and doors;to repair a dilapidation if the tenant is in substantial
(2) gas facilities maintained in good working order;violation of the following affirmative obligations:
(3) a water supply capable of producing hot and(1) The tenant is obligated to keep that part of
cold running water, and connected to a sewagethe premises which he occupies and uses clean
disposal system;and sanitary as the condition the premises permit;
(4) heating facilities maintained in good working(2) The tenant is required to properly dispose for
order;his dwelling unit all rubbish, garbage and other
(5) Electrical lighting, maintained in good workingwaste , in a clean and sanitary manner;
order;(3) The tenant is obligated to refrain from giving
(6) the building, the grounds, appurtenances, and allpermission to any person on the premises to
areas under control of the landlord starting fromwillfully destroy, deface, damage, impair or
the time of the commencement of the lease orremove any part of the structure and the tenant
rental agreement have to be kept clean, sanitary,also must refrain from doing such things;
free from all accumulations of debris, filth, rubbish,(4) The tenant is obligated to occupy the
garbage, rodents, and vermin;premises as his abode, utilizing portions for living,
(7) an adequate number of appropriatesleeping, cooking or dining purposes only as the
receptacles for garbage and rubbish, in cleandwelling was designed and intended to be used.
condition and good repair at the time of theThese are the most basic requirements, but the
commence of the lease or rental agreement, andlist of obligations and responsibilities is much
the landlord is responsible for the clean conditionbroader and imposes even more responsibilities on
and good repair of the receptacles under his orthe landlord. What is shocking, is that a landlord is
her control;allowed to legally harass a tenant, even when the
(8) floors, stairways maintained in good repair.landlord has no viable claim and is in violation of
The landlord also has to be sure he complies withthe preceding. A landlord can initiate eviction
local ordinances and any remodeling has to complyproceedings and even evict a tenant, even if the
with existing building codes.landlord is in violation of the aforementioned
A landlord of a dwelling cannot legally demandhousing violations. If the tenant is able to obtain
rent, collect rent, issue a notice of a rent increase,counsel to represent the tenant the landlord can
or issue a three day notice to pay rent or quit, iflitigate the lawsuit and then on the day of trial
the property is untenable and:simply dismiss the lawsuit.
(1) A public officer or employee who is responsibleIf the landlord alleges a contract violation as the
for the enforcement of any housing law, afterbasis of the lawsuit, the landlord can dismiss the
inspecting the premises, has notified the landlordlawsuit at the very last minute and not incur any
or the landlord's agent in writing of his or herattorney fees or costs, because if there is an
obligations to abate the nuisance or repair theattorney fee provisions in the lease agreement
substandard conditions;there is no winner when the landlord voluntarily
(2) The conditions have existed and have notdismisses the case. It is a loophole that essentially
been removed 35 days after notice was receivedencourages frivolous lawsuits. Under California law
from a public officer and the delay is not for goodthe landlord could bring a frivolous lawsuit several
cause;times and dismiss them just before trial after the
(3) and the conditions were not caused by an acttenant has exhausted thousands defending the
of the tenant or the tenants failure to act.lawsuit. This is how a landlord can harass a tenant
A landlord that demands rent, collects rent, orlegally.
issues a notice of rent increase, or issues a threeIt is not right, it is not fair, and certainly not just,
day notice to pay or quit and the four conditionsbut it is the result that was created by the State
are present then the landlord liable to the tenantLegislature.